| 2005 ALL NIWFA TEAMS | |
| FOIL | |
| FIRST TEAM | |
| Emily Hannenberg | United States Military Academy |
| Leigh Pendergrass | James Madison University |
| Julia Shih | Tufts University |
| SECOND TEAM | |
| Katie Keathley | University of Florida |
| Rachel Lieberman | Haverford University |
| Kelly Crandall | University of Florida |
| EPEE | |
| FIRST TEAM | |
| Brenda Rabel | Drew University |
| Andrea Chimel | Stevens Institute of Technology |
| Kathleen Kolakowski | Fairleigh Dickinson University |
| SECOND TEAM | |
| Lindsay Duquette | United States Military Academy |
| Sheneta Modelus | Hunter College |
| Zena Columbe | Fairleigh Dickinson University |
| SABRE | |
| FIRST TEAM | |
| Nennata Okoro | Temple University |
| Annie Holstein | John Hopkins University |
| Louis May Zovein | Tufts University |
| SECOND TEAM | |
| Ann Kim | Johns Hopkins University |
| Hali Melinitski | Haverford College |
| Taylor Artel | University of Florida |